THE scale of work required to allow the historic paddle steamer Waverley to return to Helensburgh pier is still not clear – nearly five months after the facility was closed on safety grounds.
A senior Argyll and Bute Council official told the area’s harbour board last week that “some work” would be required to the council-owned pier to allow the Waverley to visit again in future – but admitted that the authority did not yet know what that work would involve.
Stewart Clark, marine operations manager for the council, also conceded that a specialist report on the timber structure, which was expected last month, may not now arrive until the end of March.
The pier was closed to all marine traffic last October after an inspection report raised concerns over the safety of the structure.
The Waverley’s owners have already confirmed that the famous vessel will not call at Helensburgh as part of its late May bank holiday timetable, instead using Kilcreggan as a stop on two of the five days.
READ MORE: 'No surprise' as Helensburgh pier is closed to marine traffic on safety grounds
Councillors now fear a race against time to bring the Waverley to Helensburgh during her main summer season, and called for greater clarity on the situation.
The revelations were made during a verbal update on the pier’s condition at a meeting of the harbour board on March 7.
Mr Clark told the meeting: “We have carried out various on-site inspections, and run through an inspection of the timber structure with a specialist consultant who took samples of the timber.
“A structure analysis is ongoing at the moment. We had hoped it would be complete by now, but now have a completion date of the end of March at the latest.
“We have been in touch with the Waverley. They have put out an early spring timetable which does not include Helensburgh, but are awaiting updates from ourselves before they publish their summer timetable.
“The indications are that some work will be required – we are just not entirely sure what nature these will be for the timber structure.”
READ MORE: Waverley 'will come back to Helensburgh' - as long as pier is repaired
Helensburgh councillor Richard Trail, a member of the harbour board, then asked Mr Clark: “When you talk about Helensburgh pier, you give me the impression that you are optimistic that the pier might be open for commercial use in the summer.
“But if we are not getting the report finished until the end of March, and work is likely to need done, that seems a very short timescale.
“Did I misunderstand you and you are not really optimistic?”
Mr Clark responded: “We still have the option of being able to open the pier for the Waverley if works required are minimal.
“So we are hedging our bets a bit on the outcome and no decisions are being made at the moment.
“I did speak to the Waverley’s operators and we agreed that they would put out an initial spring timetable which reflected that Helensburgh was not available.
“We are still left in a position where they have to draft timetables showing Helensburgh, which they can issue from the summer.
“But we have to look at this realistically and once we know the outcome of the analysis, we will know what is required. We have to face up to it that work is likely to be needed.”
Councillor Ellen Morton, chair of the authority’s Helensburgh and Lomond area committee and vice-chair of the harbour board, said: “In a way, more clarity is bad clarity.
“None of us want bad news, but the reality is that I really don’t like where we are. However, we do have to face up to it.
“Helensburgh pier does not bring in any money, and the only vehicle to use it is the Waverley, which does not get charged berthing fees.
“But we have a policy decision that will spend money on those that bring in pier dues, and the lack of clarity on Helensburgh does not help our position.
“I would love to see Helensburgh pier being used – it would be terrible for us if it ends up out of action.
“What we want is ‘here is what is required; let’s do it’, but if that is not the message now, it needs to go out as soon as possible.
“It is a big issue for Helensburgh. It is an iconic tradition and part of Helensburgh’s summer history.
“More clarity is needed and the more positive clarity the better.”
The Advertiser previously reported on efforts by the Helensburgh Seafront Development Group, a volunteer-run community organisation, to breathe new life into the structure and nearby waterfront.
READ MORE: WW2 mine on show in Helensburgh to boost pier appeal
A spokesperson for Waverley Excursions Ltd said last week: “Waverley Excursions Ltd, which operates Paddle Steamer Waverley, is committed to sailing Waverley from Helensburgh pier and appreciates the support Helensburgh locals and visitors have shown to the ship over many years.
“We welcome the steps being taken by Argyll and Bute Council to investigate the current structural integrity of the pier and identify works required to ensure that Waverley can call at Helensburgh during her main summer season.
“While we await works on Helensburgh pier we have included additional calls at Kilcreggan during our May bank holiday sailings.”
Comments: Our rules
We want our comments to be a lively and valuable part of our community - a place where readers can debate and engage with the most important local issues. The ability to comment on our stories is a privilege, not a right, however, and that privilege may be withdrawn if it is abused or misused.
Please report any comments that break our rules.
Read the rules here